The 10 Best Combination Eye Liners & Shadows of 2025 (Reviews) - FindThisBest (2025)

"I use it on my waterline, and I think it looks really pretty! The quality is excellent, and my eyes don't feel irritated. It's somewhat waterproof and holds up well!"

"I love this cream eyeshadow stick! It glides on easily and is buildable. The light purple shade works well with my cool-toned skin. Just remember to have a jumbo pencil sharpener!"

"Using this white eyeliner on my lower lash line makes my eyes look wider and brighter. It goes on smoothly without tugging, and the shade is just right. Plus, it lasts all day!"

"This eye shadow palette is an essential in my makeup collection, and I use it daily. The colors are basic yet beautiful and very versatile, allowing me to create various looks that complement different skin tones and eye colors. Physician's Formula is one of my favorites, and this palette is in my top 3. The pigmentation is fantastic, making it easy to build color intensity. It applies smoothly and lasts all day, especially with a primer and setting spray. I highly recommend it as a basic staple!"

"I absolutely love the colors and shimmer in this palette. They stay on well throughout the day, and I have been using them for years!"

"I've been using this product for quite some time, and every time I wear this palette, I receive compliments. With my green eyes and deep red hair, these colors work great for me!"

"I found the quality amazing for the price. The colors are vivid and apply easily."

"My black cat adores the fuzzy worms! This pack is a fantastic value and I love how the bright colors help us find them easily."

"I had so much fun using these! The colors are beautiful and bright, and they last for hours!"

"I absolutely love these! I bought a set for myself and was so impressed by the beautiful pigmentation and gorgeous display box that I wanted to get more for my daughters. Unfortunately, while trying to check out, I experienced issues with a discount code not working. After several attempts, I found my items were no longer in my cart and marked as 'saved for later.' Despite this, I remain hopeful to purchase more for my girls for Christmas. These pencils go on smoothly, blend well, and last a long time!"

"I was pleasantly surprised by these pencils. They apply smoothly without any pulling, and I appreciate the wide range of colors. I didn’t think I would use the darker shades, but they look great on my pale skin. The fact that they are vegan and sourced from quality ingredients is a bonus. While the eyeshadows crease after a few hours, the lipsticks last quite a while. Overall, I'm very satisfied with the quality, especially for the price."

"Let me share my experience: DABBLE, DON'T SWIPE is my advice. The first pencil I tried broke, but I found a way to use it with a nail file. I was looking for budget-friendly eyeshadow pencils, and this set of 30 for under $25 is a steal! I do adore the metallic finishes on many colors. However, I did notice a small plastic bead in my gold pencil's cap, which makes me wonder about quality control. Overall, I’m happy with my purchase!"

"I was blown away by how creamy and pigmented this eyeliner is! It has great staying power, lasting all day without any transfer. I can't wait to explore more shades!"

"When I say this is waterproof and smudge-proof, I mean it! The quality for the price is astonishing. I use it in the corners of my eyes, and it really brightens my look!"

"I finally found a shimmer eyeliner that lasts! The color is pretty and I’m truly a customer for life. I just hope they never stop making these!"

"I’m not the best at makeup, but these eyeliners changed my game. They’re super easy to use, look fantastic, and last all day. I love using So Savage and Instafamous—the bronze and gold shades are stunning!"

"Honestly, I was blown away by this glitter liner! It’s the most beautiful and longest-lasting one I’ve tried. The white shade is incredible with its subtle lavender undertone. It's truly versatile and worth every penny!"

"I absolutely adore this eyeliner! It's hard to find colorful options, but this one stays put all day. The blue shade is gorgeous with a touch of sparkle. I can't wait to try it as an eyeshadow too!"

"At first, I found this product a bit tricky to use, but once I practiced, it became really helpful for me."

"I saw this on TikTok and was skeptical, but I ended up loving it! It really helps me achieve perfect straight lines, even better than tape."

"While I think they’re good, I’m usually in a rush and don’t use them often. However, if you have time, they definitely enhance your makeup routine."

"I was really excited about this set, but the makeup felt very chalky."

"The eyeliner was just okay, nothing special."

"I was let down by the clumpy mascara."

“I was a bit disappointed because the colors are lighter than I expected, making them somewhat hard to see. However, they glide on easily and smoothly.”

“I really wished the eyeshadow stick applied more smoothly; it feels more like a pencil and I have to press hard to get the color on my eyelid. It doesn't last that long either.”

“I found the duo set to be great! It goes on smoothly and lasted all day! I'm very pleased with my purchase.”